Holy Hill Cafe
At 1525 Carmel Rd in Hubertus, Wisconsin, Holy Hill Cafe stands as a beacon of warmth and community spirit, offering more than just a place to grab a coffee; it’s an experience that resonates deeply with both locals and visitors alike. Nestled in the serene surroundings of Holy Hill, this charming cafe harmonizes its cafe culture with a peaceful ambiance, making it an ideal spot for reflection, connection, and culinary delight.
Holy Hill Cafe specializes in a variety of homemade bakery goods, making each visit a flavorful adventure. Begin with a delightful pecan scone that strikes the perfect balance of sweetness and tender texture, and you might just find yourself unable to resist ordering seconds. For those with a sweet tooth, the outrageous brownies and magic bars are must-tries that will have your tastebuds dancing with joy. Pair your treats with a refreshing drink – the Blueberry Hibiscus tea has been praised by visitors like Austin Hribar for its lovely taste, delivered with a friendly smile by the attentive staff.
The cafe’s dining atmosphere truly sets it apart. Customers often rave about the welcoming vibe that envelops you as you walk through the door. Whether you’re there for a quiet evening or a lively weekend brunch, the friendly staff, as highlighted by Steven Schwarz, create an inviting space to enjoy your food. The reviews reflect that it’s not just about the food; it’s about the people and the experience you gain during your visit. PJ's delightful retreat at the cafe paints a picture of serenity, where each sip of the Indian peanut soup and every bite of the scone creates lasting memories.
Additionally, if you’re looking to enjoy a quick meal on the go, Holy Hill Cafe offers delicious boxed lunches. For just $15, choose your favorite sandwich, complete with chips and a beverage, providing a satisfying option for those busy days or adventures around the area.
Whether you’re a local or just passing through, Holy Hill Cafe is more than a place to eat; it’s a community hub where friendly service and fantastic food come together to create a warm, inviting atmosphere. Don’t miss your chance to immerse yourself in this gem where every visit brings the comforting essence of home, delightful flavors, and the joy of human connection.
- Baked OatmealUS$7.25
- Blueberry or Apple Cranberry QuicheUS$7.25
- Ham and Cheese, or Spinach Feta Vegetable FrittataUS$9.50
- Egg Salad SandwichUS$9.50
- Tuna Salad SandwichUS$9.50
- Chicken Salad SandwichUS$9.50
- Turkey Bacon SandwichUS$10.50
- Turkey Wrap SandwichUS$10.50
- Ham & Swiss SandwichUS$9.50
- Chicken Bacon Avocado WrapUS$10.50
- Veggie WrapUS$10.50
- Kid's PB&JUS$7.25
- Kid's Turkey & CheeseUS$7.25
- Combinations - Half sandwich and cup of soupUS$10.50
- Combinations - House salad and cup of soupUS$10.50
- Combinations - Half sandwich and half saladUS$10.50
- MuffinsUS$3.50
- SconesUS$4.25
- Chocolate Chip CookiesUS$2.50
- Oatmeal Craisin CookiesUS$2.50
- Peanut Butter CookiesUS$2.50
- Pumpkin BarsUS$3.00
- Magic BarsUS$3.00
- Turtle BarsUS$3.00
- Outrageous BrowniesUS$3.00
- Garden SaladUS$10.50
- Chicken Walnut SaladUS$10.50
- Cobb SaladUS$10.50
- BowlUS$7.50
- CupUS$4.50
- Your choice of sandwichUS$15.00
- CoffeeUS$2.35
- Espresso - Dbl shotUS$3.25
- LatteUS$4.50
- CappuccinoUS$4.75
- AmericanoUS$4.50
- Red EyeUS$4.75
- Mocha LatteUS$5.25
- Mocha BlancUS$5.25
- CortadoUS$3.25
- Milk Alternative - Oat milk or Almond MilkUS$1.00
- FlavorsUS$0.75
- Espresso shotUS$0.75
- Chai Tea LatteUS$4.25
- Hot ChocolateUS$2.55
- SteamerUS$3.25
- Organic Rishi TeaUS$3.25
- London FogUS$3.95
64 Reviews
22 Sep 2025
20 Sep 2025
25 Jul 2025
08 Jul 2025
07 Jun 2025
Café 5ta. Avenida
The Chef's Kitchen
Brim Cafe & Catering
Mad Ave Nutrition
Join the Holy Hill Cafe Newsletter
Get the latest updates on seasonal pastries, special events, and local highlights directly in your inbox.